首頁 / 趨勢風向儀

打擊毒品顧立雄對上成衣業者，誰勝誰敗？杜特蒂緝毒下場多悽慘？(有圖）

2016/08/09 駐站編輯 駐站編輯
標籤,,

顧立雄上週舉辦公聽話，主張台灣毒品氾濫問題嚴重，現今毒品犯罪重刑化的方針徒然讓監獄人滿為患，卻無法有效降低吸毒者的再犯率，因此他希望提出「毒品危害防制條例部分條文修正草案」，明定「戒癮治療」為觀察、勒戒、強制戒治的前置醫療程序，希望能夠根本降低毒品相關犯罪。

但網路名嘴成衣商朱學恆則批評這是將毒品除罪化，在臉書上批評：「一輩子沒有吸過二手K毒，被毒品犯搶奪傷害偷竊刺殺過的理想派不分區立委，不但反對K他命改為二級毒品，他和他的快樂夥伴們甚至主張一、二級毒品（海洛因、鴉片、古柯鹼、嗎啡、安非他命）吸食者只要能夠戒癮，通通應該除罪化，連強制勒戒或是入獄服刑都不用，要恢復他們的正常生活。」

12

↑立委顧立雄與網路名嘴朱學恆　照片取自新頭殼、蘋果日報

在網路上引起正反兩派的激烈論戰，支持顧立雄者認為把吸毒者更加推往社會的邊緣只是更鼓勵他們再犯，支持朱學恆者則認為不把吸毒的人抓去關是太過理想，不切實際。

3

4↑這次毒品相關的論戰讓朱學恆（圖左）顧立雄（圖右）的負面聲量都暴增

而在國內爭吵不休的同時，鄰近的菲律賓更加的不平靜，鐵血總統貫徹他上任前所宣示的向毒品宣戰諾言，當選後即向執法部門表示全力支持反毒品行動，甚至言明可將拒捕者殺之已經有超過800名涉毒嫌犯被軍方、警方甚至民間「義警」當街擊斃，人權團體則表示這樣罔顧生命權跟司法的做法不該被允許。

MANILA, PHILIPPINES - JUNE 25: (EDITORS NOTE: This image contains graphic content) A drug suspect is killed in a shootout during a buy bust operation conducted by police on June 25, 2016 in Manila, Philippines. The president-elect of the Philippines, Rodrigo Duterte, declared a war on crime and drugs after sweeping an election on May 9 and has been living up to his nickname, "the punisher". Philippine police have been conducting night raids almost on a daily basis and revived a curfew for minors that had not been enforced for years, rounding up minors drinking on the streets. Based on local reports, there has been at least 59 drug-related deaths since the election and hundreds of drug suspects arrested over one month as Duterte reassured police on his full support if they killed criminals who resisted with violence. The raids have caused concern for Catholic church officials and human rights advocates as Duterte officially takes his oath as the 16th president of the Republic of the Philippines on June 30. (Photo by Dondi Tawatao/Getty Images)

↑2016年6月25日，菲律賓馬尼拉警察緝毒行動中，一名毒販被槍殺。（ 圖片來源：Dondi Tawatao/Getty image）

獲得特許跟拍警方查緝毒品行動的菲律賓攝影師Dondi表示：「一方面，人們支持保護孩子、打擊毒品，另一方面，也得尊重任何人都不應被無理殺害的基本人權。」

6

↑上週毒品議題在國內國外都有許多討論，聲量高低依序是杜特蒂、顧立雄、朱學恆

7

↑但讓人訝異的是獲得最少負面聲量的是對付毒品手段最極端的杜特蒂，其次是認為毒品需有高刑責的朱學恆、最多負面批評的則是主張醫療前至化的顧立雄。

藉由這樣的聲量結果我們似乎可以推測，台灣網友即使不那麼贊同杜特蒂不經司法審判給與警察偌大權限的做法，但對毒品就該藉由嚴刑峻法，將施用毒品者從正常社會中排除的價值多半是贊同的。

MANILA, PHILIPPINES - JUNE 16: Suspected drug users and drug dealers are arrested by police during a night time raid on a suspected drug den on June 16, 2016 in Manila, Philippines. The president-elect of the Philippines, Rodrigo Duterte, declared a war on crime and drugs after sweeping an election on May 9 and has been living up to his nickname, "the punisher". Philippine police have been conducting night raids almost on a daily basis and revived a curfew for minors that had not been enforced for years, rounding up minors drinking on the streets. Based on local reports, there has been at least 59 drug-related deaths since the election and hundreds of drug suspects arrested over one month as Duterte reassured police on his full support if they killed criminals who resisted with violence. The raids have caused concern for Catholic church officials and human rights advocates as Duterte officially takes his oath as the 16th president of the Republic of the Philippines on June 30. (Photo by Dondi Tawatao/Getty Images)

↑2016年6月16日，菲律賓馬尼拉，警方將疑為吸毒者與毒販拘捕。（圖片來源：Dondi Tawatao/Getty images）

這讓小編想起鄭捷案後台灣社會對於死刑的論辯，究竟殺人犯/毒品施用者有沒有教化可能？而嚴刑峻法對於這樣子的社會邊緣人能夠產生嚇阻作用，還是更將他們推往絕路？

這樣的論辯迄今我們的社會還無法找到共識，無差別殺人的恐懼仍存於你我的日常，毒品濫用仍致造下一個破碎的家庭，究竟當代的社會及世界出了什麼問題又該如何挽救我們仍無法得到答案，甚至我們也不確定是否有答案，唯一能肯定的是，尋求答案的代價除了時間、無數的性命及金錢，甚至可能是我們人性中的善良，以及希望。

9

「與怪物戰鬥的人，應當小心自己不要成為怪物。當你凝視深淵，深淵也凝視著你。」－尼采

上一篇：
下一篇：

您可能會有興趣

留點回應